Summary: With NIH funding tighter and more competitive than ever, every proposal must be tailored to its funder. Lead with why your work matters, and match the funder’s current mission. Use NIH RePORTER and its matchmaker tool to find the right NIH institute. To find funders, talk to program officials, network at conferences, and check the acknowledgments in related papers. For NIH, keep specific aims narrow and independent of each other; foundations allow more overlap but vary widely. One proposal sent to every funder backfires, so build relationships early and check your draft against the review criteria.

The new landscape of research funding has challenged the very core of academic science. With the changes the National Institute of Health (NIH) implemented in the last 2 years, several scientists found themselves wondering what would happen with their funding. Fortunately, private foundations and philanthropies are stepping up and opening new paths to funding. But their rules and policies, and the way they approach a proposal, differ from the NIH.
We interviewed Ellen Kuwana, MS, who is a grant writer and editor with over 20 years’ experience in scientific communications. In this series of three blogs, she walks us through the strategic and tactical approaches to this new funding landscape. You can also listen to Ellen’s full webinar on our webinar page.
Scientific Communication
Expert Ellen Kuwana, MS
Parse: When writing a grant, what challenges do researchers face when adapting the same core science for an NIH proposal versus a philanthropic letter of intent?
Ellen: Today we are fighting for funding, and it’s more competitive than it has ever been. It used to be that the top 50% of grants scored got funded, roughly 1 in 10 submissions. Now only the top third even gets scored at all. The middle third gets no score or feedback. And of that top third, you have roughly a fifty-fifty chance of getting funded.
It is paramount that any funding request should be framed based on who/where you are submitting it.
Think about the reader. Who’s the audience? What’s your purpose?
Elevate what you want to highlight in a concise, clear way for a reader who may not have expertise in your specific area, but who is smart and has a scientific background. Be very clear about defining your terms, giving context, and explaining the why: Why should the reader care? This is the most important information, put it first.
If you write for a foundation, the framing has to align closely with the mission of the philanthropic organization or foundation you’re sending it to.
Even within the NIH there are about 26 centers and institutes, so go to NIH RePORTER (https://reporter.nih.gov/) to find yours.
In the NIH matchmaker tool, you can upload an abstract or scientific text. It will pull up already-funded grants that match yours most closely. You can see which institutes and centers fund that type of research. There’s also a bar graph showing which institutes give out the most money.
Sometimes it’s advantageous to go to the ones funding a lot of projects; in other instances, it’s better to go to a lesser-known one. Talking to the program official can clarify that.
It helps to work with a communications specialist or give the draft to someone in a slightly different field and have them physically cross out what they find uninteresting, or too detailed.
Parse: On the strategy side, how does a scientist decide which funder is most advantageous to approach?
Ellen: Regarding the NIH specifically, in the good old days you would talk to the program official.
But there’s been a lot of movement lately, voluntary and involuntary layoffs, and people are covering more territory than before, or territory they didn’t used to cover. There’s a lot of variability, and the landscape is changing so rapidly that it’s hard to reach someone who really knows the lay of the land. This uncharted territory is harder to navigate.
In general, the more people you can talk to, the better: go to scientific conferences, go to AAAS, go to conferences in your specialty area, and really talk to people.
At conferences, snap a picture of the thank you slide at the end of a talk, the one that flashes for three seconds listing funders as it tells you where the funding came from.
Look up papers by people doing similar work and skip straight to the acknowledgments section to see who they thank, what the grant number was, and which center funded it. You’ll often find smaller funders there too: philanthropies, foundations, and nonprofits.
Parse: NIH rewards hypothesis-driven rigor, whereas philanthropies such as CZI reward vision and collaboration. Have you seen researchers overcorrect, making an NIH proposal too speculative, or a foundation letter of intent too methodological because they didn’t fully shift registers? What do you recommend?
Ellen: I agree that happens. Although I would add that NIH itself is increasingly emphasizing collaboration and multidisciplinary approaches, recognizing that no single place or person has everything needed. And CZI has shifted its research focus substantially over the past year or so. So really know the funder’s current mission and recent funding history and align to that. Again, for NIH, talk early and often with the program official. They’re responsible for the programmatic and scientific aspects of the grant and can review short paragraphs and give you up-to-date guidance on how to pivot given current conditions.
Regardless of the specific funder, you need a clear rationale behind your hypotheses and the research designs and methods you chose.
I think the most common error I see in NIH grants is too broad or too many specific aims. I recommend getting colleagues to read the draft for substantive feedback on scope: Is this project actually doable within the timeline and budget?
Even when you have resources, a timeline, and milestones for innovation-type grants, you may need to sharpen and trim your aims.
I have seen people stumbling on another aspect of the aim section.
NIH wants specific aims independent from one another: Aim 2 cannot depend on Aim 1 succeeding. If you’re building a prototype, you need a workaround for any component that might fail. What happens if you get a negative result, or if a piece just doesn’t work while the other two do?
Foundations are more lenient: You can have more interdependent aims, but they should still be clear and distinct.
Foundation and philanthropy grants can’t really be lumped into one bucket, though; they vary enormously.
Foundations tend to have fewer templates, they are less prescribed, and that ambiguity can lead people to spill too much onto the page, making it disorganized.
Parse: Have you seen a research team try to write one proposal and send it, with minimal changes, to multiple funder types? Does that ever work, or does it backfire?
Ellen: Quick answer: It backfires. Each proposal needs to be specifically tailored, especially in this competitive landscape. It’s like a form letter asking for donations (it doesn’t work)—but if someone takes the time to write a genuinely compelling story, it grabs attention. It’s not just how you present it, but what you’re saying, and how personal a connection you have to the foundation. You need to make those calls, have those conversations or emails.
Do some pre-work: An established relationship with a foundation before you submit matters enormously, so they know you are checking in: Does this proposal align with your purpose? If not now, could it move in that direction? It’s like going to a professor’s office hours, you get participation points for trying.
NIH’s requests for proposals always include a section on review criteria, so check that and build your rubric or checklist from it.
There aren’t really shortcuts if you want to get funded. It’s too competitive right now.
In the next blog Ellen will discuss communication styles to persuade.